Cole Caufield Rookie Cards Guide

Published: May 31, 2025

⏱️ 6 min read

Track Your Collection with
Hall of Cards

Want to keep track of your sports cards and manage your collection? Download our free app to scan cards, track values, and stay updated with the latest market trends.

Download Now

Table of Contents

Introduction

Cole Caufield, the dynamic forward for the Montreal Canadiens, has quickly become one of the most exciting young players in the NHL. His explosive scoring ability and marketable personality have made his rookie cards highly sought after by collectors. In this guide, we’ll explore the most valuable and desirable Cole Caufield rookie cards on the market.

Key Takeaways:

  • The 2021-22 Upper Deck Young Guns card is Caufield’s most iconic rookie, with base versions ranging from $50-100 and High Gloss exceeding $500.
  • The Cup Rookie Patch Auto represents the highest-end option, with base versions at $1,000-2,000 and low-numbered parallels reaching $4,000+.
  • SP Authentic Future Watch Autos offer the best balance of prestige and accessibility at $200-1,000 depending on parallel and condition.
  • Caufield’s scoring ability and Montreal Canadiens franchise appeal make his cards attractive long-term holds for collectors and investors.
  • Focus on graded examples (PSA 10 or BGS 9.5+) and cards with on-card autographs for maximum investment potential.

1. 2021-22 Upper Deck Young Guns

The Young Guns rookie card is the most iconic and widely collected rookie card in hockey. Caufield’s Young Guns card (#249) features him in his Montreal Canadiens uniform and has become the cornerstone of his rookie card collection. The card’s value has remained strong due to its high demand and limited print run.

  • Base Young Guns: $50-100

  • Young Guns Canvas: $100-200

  • Young Guns High Gloss: $500+

2. 2021-22 SP Authentic Future Watch Auto

The SP Authentic Future Watch Auto is one of the most prestigious rookie cards in the hobby. Caufield’s version features his on-card autograph and a limited print run, making it highly desirable among collectors. The card’s value is supported by its premium quality and the player’s potential for future success.

  • Base Future Watch Auto: $200-400

  • Future Watch Auto Patch: $500-1000

  • Future Watch Auto Patch /99: $1000+

3. 2021-22 The Cup Rookie Patch Auto

As the highest-end product in Upper Deck’s lineup, The Cup features premium rookie cards with multiple patches and autographs. Caufield’s Rookie Patch Auto cards are among the most valuable in his rookie year, featuring game-worn patches and on-card autographs.

  • Base Rookie Patch Auto: $1000-2000

  • Rookie Patch Auto /99: $2000-4000

  • Rookie Patch Auto /25: $4000+

4. 2021-22 O-Pee-Chee Platinum

The O-Pee-Chee Platinum rookie cards offer a more affordable entry point for collectors while still maintaining high quality and visual appeal. Caufield’s rookie cards in this set feature modern designs and various parallels that are popular among collectors.

  • Base Rookie: $20-40

  • Rookie Auto: $100-200

  • Rookie Auto Patch: $200-400

5. 2021-22 Artifacts

The Artifacts set is known for its beautiful design and premium materials. Caufield’s rookie cards in this set feature various parallels and patch variations, making them attractive to collectors looking for unique pieces.

  • Base Rookie: $15-30

  • Rookie Patch: $100-200

  • Rookie Patch Auto: $300-600

Investment Potential

Cole Caufield’s rookie cards present an interesting investment opportunity for collectors. His scoring ability and marketability make his cards attractive long-term holds. However, as with any sports card investment, it’s important to:

  • Focus on high-grade examples (PSA 10 or BGS 9.5+). Learn more about grading sports trading cards to ensure you submit only the best candidates.

  • Target cards with on-card autographs

  • Consider cards with game-worn patches

  • Look for numbered parallels with low print runs. Understanding how to build value in your sports card collection will help you make informed decisions about which Caufield cards to pursue.

Looking to expand your sports card knowledge? Check out these related guides:

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most valuable Cole Caufield rookie card?

The most valuable Caufield rookie card is The Cup Rookie Patch Auto /25 or lower numbered versions, with values exceeding $4,000. However, for most collectors, the Upper Deck Young Guns remains the most iconic and widely collected, with High Gloss versions valued at $500+. The SP Authentic Future Watch Auto represents the best balance of prestige and accessibility, typically ranging from $200-1,000 depending on parallel and condition.

Are Cole Caufield rookie cards a good investment?

Caufield’s cards present moderate investment potential based on his scoring ability and playing for the storied Montreal Canadiens franchise. His value depends heavily on continued offensive production and potential playoff success. For long-term investment, focus on graded examples (PSA 10 or BGS 9.5+) of flagship products like Young Guns and SP Authentic Future Watch Autos. However, be aware that forward positions generally hold less value than defensemen or goaltenders unless they achieve elite superstar status.

Should I grade my Cole Caufield Young Guns rookie card?

If your Young Guns card appears to have excellent centering, sharp corners, and a clean surface, grading can significantly increase its value. A PSA 10 Young Guns typically sells for 3-5x the price of a raw near-mint copy. However, grading costs $20-40 depending on service level, so only submit if you’re confident in achieving a 9.5 or 10 grade. Cards with any visible flaws, off-centering, or edge wear should remain raw.

Where can I buy authentic Cole Caufield rookie cards?

Purchase Caufield rookie cards from reputable sources including COMC, eBay (from sellers with high feedback ratings), local card shops, and major online retailers like Blowout Cards or Steel City Collectibles. For high-value purchases (over $500), prioritize graded cards from PSA, BGS, or SGC to ensure authenticity. Avoid deals that seem too good to be true, and always verify seller credentials before purchasing expensive autographed or memorabilia cards.

Conclusion

Cole Caufield’s rookie cards offer collectors a chance to own pieces of hockey history from one of the game’s most exciting young talents. Whether you’re a Canadiens fan, a card collector, or an investor, his rookie cards present various opportunities to build a meaningful collection. Remember to always buy from reputable sources and consider the condition and authenticity of the cards you’re purchasing.