TCG Grading Guide: Pokemon, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh

Table of Contents

• Introduction: Why Grade TCG Cards?
• Understanding Card Grading Companies
• PSA vs BGS vs CGC: Detailed Comparison
• 2026 Grading Costs and Fees
• Grading Different TCG Types
• When to Grade Your Cards
• How to Prepare Cards for Grading
• Return on Investment Analysis
• Frequently Asked Questions
• Conclusion

Introduction: Why Grade TCG Cards?

Professional grading authenticates your trading cards and provides a universally recognized condition assessment, substantially increasing value, boosting buyer confidence, and ensuring long-term protection. In 2026, graded TCG cards command 2-5x premiums over raw cards for Pokemon, Magic: The Gathering, and Yu-Gi-Oh cards in top grades.

Grading evaluates cards across multiple criteria:

• Authentication - Verifies card legitimacy
• Corners - Assesses sharpness and wear
• Edges - Examines fraying and damage
• Surface - Inspects scratches, print lines, indentations
• Centering - Measures border alignment and symmetry

PSA 10 (Gem Mint) cards can command 4-10x prices over raw cards for high-demand collectibles, making grading a critical decision for valuable TCG cards.

Key Insight: Only grade cards worth $50+ in raw condition with Near Mint or better appearance, as grading costs ($12-$25+ per card) must be justified by potential value increase.

Key Takeaways:

• PSA dominates Pokemon grading with 90% market share, while BGS leads in Magic: The Gathering
• Grading costs $12-$25+ per card; only grade cards worth $50+ in raw condition
• PSA 10 cards command 2-5x premiums over raw cards for high-demand collectibles
• CGC offers fastest turnaround times (15-20 business days) and most affordable bulk rates
• Only submit Near Mint or better cards with strong centering for best grading ROI

Understanding Card Grading Companies

The Big Three Grading Services

PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator)

• Established 1991, industry leader
• Largest population report database
• Highest resale premiums for most cards
• Dominates Pokemon grading (90% market share)

BGS/Beckett (Beckett Grading Services)

• Established 1999, known for strict grading
• Detailed sub-grade system (Centering, Corners, Edges, Surface)
• “Black Label” BGS 10 (all four 10 sub-grades) extremely prestigious
• Dominates Magic: The Gathering grading market

CGC (Certified Guaranty Company)

• Newer to trading cards (launched 2020)
• Most affordable bulk rates ($12+ per card)
• Crystal-clear slabs with excellent presentation
• Rapidly gaining market acceptance

Smaller Grading Services

SGC (Sportscard Guaranty): Focused primarily on sports cards, less common for TCG

Other services: TAG, HGA—niche players with limited market acceptance for TCG cards

PSA vs BGS vs CGC: Detailed Comparison

Grading Scales

PSA Scale (1-10, whole numbers only):

• 10 = Gem Mint
• 9 = Mint
• 8 = Near Mint-Mint
• 7 = Near Mint
• Lower grades rarely submitted for TCG

BGS/Beckett Scale (1-10 with sub-grades):

• 10 = Pristine (perfect card)
• 9.5 = Gem Mint (with 9.5+ sub-grades)
• 9 = Mint
• Black Label 10 = All four sub-grades perfect 10

CGC Scale (1-10 with half-points):

• 10 = Gem Mint (formerly labeled 9.5)
• 9.5 = Mint+
• 9 = Mint
• Revised scale in 2023 made CGC 10s more comparable to PSA 10s

Grading Philosophy Differences

PSA: Sometimes considered slightly more lenient on centering and minor flaws, making PSA 10s relatively common on modern cards with good quality control.

BGS: Very strict grading standards. A BGS 9.5 is roughly equivalent to a PSA 10. BGS Pristine 10 and Black Label 10 are extremely rare and command massive premiums.

CGC: Middle ground between PSA and BGS. After 2023 scale revision, CGC 10s are directly competitive with PSA 10s.

Market Preference by Card Type

Pokemon Cards:

• PSA dominates with estimated 90% of graded Pokemon sales on eBay
• PSA-graded Pokemon cards command highest resale values
• CGC gaining ground due to lower costs, gap closing to 70-85% of PSA values

Magic: The Gathering Cards:

• BGS dominates the MTG grading market
• MTG players prefer seeing sub-grades for condition assessment
• BGS Black Label 10s command exceptional premiums

Yu-Gi-Oh Cards:

• Mixed market with PSA and BGS both popular
• Grading interest surged around late 2020
• PSA slight edge for vintage cards, BGS for modern competition cards

Slab Design and Protection

PSA: Thin, lightweight slabs with classic design. Easy to stack and store in bulk.

BGS: Thicker, heavier slabs. Sub-grades prominently displayed. Premium feel.

CGC: Middle ground thickness. Ultra-clear plastic gives crystal-clear card view. Modern aesthetic.

Resale Value Comparison

PSA: Highest resale premiums for most TCG categories, particularly Pokemon

BGS: Highest premiums for Magic: The Gathering, competitive with PSA for high-grade cards

CGC: Moderate premiums (70-85% of equivalent PSA grades), but gap closing as CGC establishes credibility

Black Label BGS 10: Commands massive premiums—can be 5-10x more valuable than regular PSA/BGS 10s

2026 Grading Costs and Fees

PSA Pricing (2026)

Bulk Services (Membership Required):

• Trading Card Game Bulk: $18.99/card (20 card minimum)
• Value Bulk: $21.99/card (5 card minimum)
• Regular Service: $80/card (standard turnaround)
• Express: $150-$200/card (faster processing)
• Premium: $300+/card (priority handling)

Turnaround Times:

• Bulk: 2-6 months
• Regular: 30-60 days
• Express: 2-3 weeks
• Premium: 5-10 business days

PSA Membership: ~$99-$199/year depending on tier

BGS Pricing (2026)

Standard Grading:

• Bulk submissions: $18-$22/card depending on volume
• Standard: $30-$50/card
• Express: $100-$150/card
• Premium: $250+/card

Sub-Grade Options: Available at all service levels

Turnaround: Similar to PSA (bulk 2-6 months, express 2-4 weeks)

CGC Pricing (2026)

Most Affordable Option:

• Bulk rates: Starting around $12/card for large submissions
• Standard: $15-$18/card
• Express: $40-$75/card
• Premium: $150+/card

Turnaround: Faster than PSA/BGS at bulk level (6-12 weeks typical)

No membership required for most service levels

Cost Comparison Summary

For bulk submissions (20+ cards):

• CGC: ~$12/card (best value)
• PSA: ~$19/card (membership required)
• BGS: ~$18-22/card

For standard individual cards:

• CGC: ~$15-18/card
• PSA: ~$22/card
• BGS: ~$30/card

Grading Different TCG Types

Pokemon Card Grading

Best Service: PSA (highest resale value) Alternative: CGC (best cost efficiency)

What to grade:

• Vintage holofoils (Base Set, Jungle, Fossil, Neo series)
• Modern ultra-rares (Charizard, Pikachu, legendary Pokemon)
• First Edition cards
• Japanese exclusive cards
• Promotional cards

Grading tips:

• Japanese cards typically grade better (superior quality control)
• Modern Pokemon cards with good centering often achieve PSA 10
• Vintage cards challenging to grade 10 due to print quality issues

ROI expectations:

• Cards worth $100+ raw: 120-300% increase for PSA 10
• Cards worth $50-100 raw: 80-150% increase for PSA 10
• Cards below $50: Often doesn’t justify grading cost

Magic: The Gathering Grading

Best Service: BGS (market prefers sub-grades) Alternative: PSA for vintage Reserved List cards

What to grade:

• Reserved List cards (Power 9, Dual Lands, early rares)
• Vintage cards from Alpha, Beta, Unlimited, Revised
• Foil versions of competitive staples
• Serialized Universes Beyond cards

Grading tips:

• MTG cards printed before ~2003 difficult to grade 10
• Foils susceptible to curling—only grade perfectly flat cards
• Reserved List cards benefit greatly from authentication

ROI expectations:

• Reserved List cards: Grading provides authentication premium (20-100%)
• Modern foils: 2-10x multiplier for BGS 9.5+
• Vintage rares: PSA 8+ adds 50-200% value

Yu-Gi-Oh Card Grading

Best Service: PSA for vintage, PSA/BGS for modern Alternative: CGC for bulk modern cards

What to grade:

• 1st Edition vintage cards (2002-2006)
• Tournament prize cards
• Starlight Rares
• Ghost Rares
• Quarter Century Secret Rares

Grading tips:

• Yu-Gi-Oh cards often have print lines (affects grading)
• 1st Edition designation crucial for value
• Tournament prize cards benefit from authentication

ROI expectations:

• 1st Edition vintage: 2-5x increase for PSA 9-10
• Starlight Rares: 20-50% premium for PSA 10
• Tournament prizes: Authentication value significant

When to Grade Your Cards

Financial Threshold: The $50 Rule

Only grade cards worth $50+ in raw condition that appear Near Mint (NM) or better. With grading costs ranging $12-25+ per card, you need significant value increase potential to justify the expense.

Condition Assessment

Before grading, inspect cards carefully:

✓ Good Candidates for Grading:

• Sharp, clean corners
• Smooth edges with no whitening
• Centered within acceptable range (60/40 or better)
• Clean surface with no scratches or print defects
• No bends, creases, or dents

✗ Poor Candidates for Grading:

• Visible corner wear or rounding
• Edge whitening or fraying
• Off-center printing (worse than 65/35)
• Surface scratches, indentations, print lines
• Any creases, bends, or water damage

Strategic Grading Decisions

Grade for:

• Long-term collection preservation
• Cards you plan to sell (graded = higher prices)
• Authentication of expensive cards
• Cards likely to appreciate significantly
• Low population candidates (few PSA 10s exist)

Don’t grade:

• Cards worth under $50 raw
• Cards you’re unsure about selling
• Cards with visible flaws
• Common/bulk cards regardless of condition

How to Prepare Cards for Grading

Pre-Submission Inspection

1. Use magnification - 10x loupe or magnifying glass
2. Bright lighting - Inspect under good light source
3. Check all surfaces - Front, back, edges, corners
4. Research populations - Check PSA population reports for realistic expectations

Cleaning (If Necessary)

Gentle cleaning only:

• Use microfiber cloth
• Gentle dabbing motion (never rub)
• Only remove fingerprints or light dust
• Never use liquids or cleaning solutions

Protective Sleeves

1. Penny sleeve - Standard card sleeve (avoid tight fit)
2. Card saver or top-loader for shipping
3. Never use magnetic holders or rigid cases
4. Keep cards flat and secure

Submission Forms

Accurate information required:

• Card name and set
• Year and manufacturer
• Any special designations (1st Edition, Promo, etc.)
• Declared value (for insurance)

Digital submissions: Most companies now accept online submissions with tracking

Shipping

Pack securely:

• Card savers or semi-rigid holders
• Bubble mailer or small box
• Adequate padding
• Insured shipping for valuable cards

Track everything: Use tracking numbers and delivery confirmation

Return on Investment Analysis

Pokemon Card ROI

High-value cards ($100+ raw):

• PSA 10: 120-300% value increase
• PSA 9: 30-80% value increase
• PSA 8: 10-40% value increase

Mid-tier cards ($50-100 raw):

• PSA 10: 80-150% value increase
• PSA 9: 20-50% value increase

Lower-value cards ($10-50 raw):

• Often fails to justify grading cost
• Exception: Low population candidates

Magic: The Gathering ROI

Reserved List cards:

• Authentication premium: 20-100%
• BGS 9.5+: Additional 50-200%
• Vintage (Alpha/Beta): 100-500% for high grades

Modern competitive cards:

• BGS 9.5+ foils: 2-10x multiplier
• Regular rares: Often not worth grading

Yu-Gi-Oh ROI

1st Edition vintage ($100+ raw):

• PSA 10: 200-400% increase
• PSA 9: 50-150% increase

Modern Starlight Rares:

• PSA 10: 20-50% premium
• Strong demand justifies grading

Market Liquidity

Graded cards sell faster:

• Most PSA 10s: 7-14 days to sell
• Vintage graded cards: Dedicated collector market
• Modern playables: Quick sales on TCGPlayer, eBay

Frequently Asked Questions

Which grading company should I use for Pokemon cards?

PSA is the gold standard for Pokemon with highest resale values and 90% market share. CGC offers better cost efficiency at $12/card bulk rates, though CGC cards sell for 70-85% of equivalent PSA grades. The value gap is closing as CGC gains market acceptance.

Is BGS or PSA better for Magic: The Gathering?

BGS dominates the MTG grading market because players prefer seeing sub-grades for condition analysis. BGS Black Label 10s are extremely prestigious and valuable. PSA is acceptable for vintage Reserved List cards where authentication matters most.

How much does card grading cost in 2026?

Bulk rates: CGC ~$12/card, PSA ~$19/card (membership required), BGS ~$18-22/card. Individual submissions: CGC $15-18, PSA $22, BGS $30. Express services $40-200+ depending on company and turnaround time desired.

How long does card grading take?

Bulk submissions: 2-6 months typically. Standard service: 30-60 days. Express: 2-4 weeks. Premium: 5-10 business days. CGC generally faster than PSA/BGS for bulk submissions.

Should I grade modern or vintage cards?

Vintage cards in high grades (PSA 8+) command significant premiums due to scarcity and authentication value. Modern cards with strong competitive demand or low population candidates also worth grading. Focus on cards worth $50+ raw in Near Mint condition.

What’s a PSA 10 worth compared to raw?

PSA 10 cards command 2-5x premiums over raw cards for most collectibles. High-demand cards can see 5-10x multipliers. The premium depends on card desirability, scarcity, and whether the card is vintage or modern.

Can I grade cards myself?

No, professional authentication and grading requires submission to established companies (PSA, BGS, CGC). “Self-grading” for personal assessment is possible using online guides, but official grades require third-party authentication.

Related Articles

Pokemon Card Value Guide 2026 How to Spot Fake TCG Cards PSA vs BGS vs SGC Grading Comparison When to Grade Sports Cards

Conclusion

Grading TCG cards in 2026 remains a powerful tool for protecting valuable collectibles, increasing market value, and ensuring authenticity. Whether you’re grading Pokemon cards for PSA’s market dominance, Magic cards for BGS’s detailed sub-grades, or Yu-Gi-Oh cards for authentication and premium pricing, understanding costs, ROI potential, and best practices ensures smart grading decisions.

Key Takeaways:

• Only grade cards worth $50+ raw in Near Mint condition
• PSA dominates Pokemon (90% market), BGS dominates Magic, both compete for Yu-Gi-Oh
• 2026 costs: CGC bulk ($12), PSA bulk ($19), BGS bulk ($18-22)
• PSA 10 cards command 2-5x premiums over raw equivalents
• Proper preparation maximizes grading results

Hall of Cards simplifies the grading decision process by providing instant AI-powered valuations of your TCG cards based on real eBay sales data. Know exactly what your cards are worth before committing to grading costs, and make informed decisions about which cards justify professional authentication.

---

Download Hall of Cards free for iOS and Android. Get instant AI valuations for Pokemon, Magic: The Gathering, and Yu-Gi-Oh cards to make smart grading decisions.